Maulana Arshad Madani, President of Jamiat Ulema-e-Hind, has criticized the proposal, stating that making the song compulsory is a direct violation of the freedom of religion guaranteed by the Constitution. He argued that such a move negatively impacts the rights of minorities. According to Madani, the mandatory imposition of any anthem or song that conflicts with personal religious beliefs undermines the democratic fabric of the country.
The Indian Union Muslim League (IUML) has also joined the protest, with National Vice President Maulana Kausar Hayat Khan questioning the government’s intent. He pointed out that objections to certain verses of Vande Mataram date back to the pre-independence era due to their conflict with Islamic monotheistic beliefs. “Do you want to convert all Muslims in the country into Hindus?” he asked rhetorically, warning that forcing such decisions is detrimental to national unity.
The debate has escalated as political leaders weigh in, with some supporting the move as a gesture of patriotism and others viewing it as an infringement on individual liberties. Meanwhile, social media is abuzz with varying opinions, including YSRCP leader Vijayasaid Reddy sharing the full lyrics of the song to emphasize its historical importance. As tensions rise, legal experts suggest that the matter may eventually be challenged in the higher courts to determine the constitutional validity of the mandate.
